Usually, I'm a big fan of Noah Carl, but I'm afraid I don't fully accept his analysis here. Rather, this is another case where I'll believe my "lying eyes" rather than government statistics. The fact that the arrest rate of muslims/immigrants in Britain is not significantly higher than that for the native population is not terribly surprising given the double standard British police have shown when it comes to enforcing the law. The British police are among the most woke on the planet, and have clearly adopted a "hands off" policy when it comes to Muslims. The grooming gangs scandal was one of the sickest examples of police negligence, written off as a "moral panic" by the apologists.
One thing that might explain the dissonance of the dissident right’s view of crime and race is inter-ethnic crime. Are white Brits robbing, raping and murdering East Asians, Blacks and Muslims? Are East Asians, Blacks and Muslims assaulting their own communities or are they raping white girls, robbing white businesses and beating outside the tribe? Also - do these ethnic communities go to the official police for resolution of conflicts and transgressions inside their communities?
Great episode Alex! Will we ever see Louise Perry make a return to the show? She talks more now about demography and collapse Especially in the context of Britain. It’s fascinating but kinda terrifying. I would love to see her back on! x
Freya India would also make for a great guest. Her work is amazing :)
Let’s compare crime rates in the UK with those in Poland. I’m giving the crime index measured as crimes per 1,000 residents (so the higher the number the more crime), and safety index scores from 0-100, where a low figure means people feel very unsafe and a high score means they feel very safe.
UK crime index 48.
Poland crime index 25.
In other words, crime in the UK is running at maybe twice the level of Poland. Figures for individual cities suggest that the disparity is actually far greater.
Polish Safety Perceptions:
People in Poland feel safer walking alone both during the day (83.35) and at night (61.70) compared to the UK, where safety is rated at 67.49 for daytime and 41.93 for nighttime.
Specific Crime Concerns:
The UK has more issues with drug-related crimes, with a score of 63.61 compared to Poland’s 28.29. Property crimes and vandalism are also much higher in the UK.
Violent crime, such as assault and armed robbery, is more prevalent in the UK, with a score of 46.08, compared to a very low 18.18 in Poland.
Individual cities:
Warsaw, the Polish capital, has a crime index of 25.3 and a safety index of 74.7. The city is considered very safe for walking alone during the day (88.8) and fairly safe at night (67.9). Most types of violent crime, such as assault and robbery, are rare. I couldn’t find figures for Poland’s second and third cities Kraków and Łódź, but the impression is, they’re lower than Warsaw.
Here are the crime index figures for some English cities, compared to Warsaw:
Usually, I'm a big fan of Noah Carl, but I'm afraid I don't fully accept his analysis here. Rather, this is another case where I'll believe my "lying eyes" rather than government statistics. The fact that the arrest rate of muslims/immigrants in Britain is not significantly higher than that for the native population is not terribly surprising given the double standard British police have shown when it comes to enforcing the law. The British police are among the most woke on the planet, and have clearly adopted a "hands off" policy when it comes to Muslims. The grooming gangs scandal was one of the sickest examples of police negligence, written off as a "moral panic" by the apologists.
One thing that might explain the dissonance of the dissident right’s view of crime and race is inter-ethnic crime. Are white Brits robbing, raping and murdering East Asians, Blacks and Muslims? Are East Asians, Blacks and Muslims assaulting their own communities or are they raping white girls, robbing white businesses and beating outside the tribe? Also - do these ethnic communities go to the official police for resolution of conflicts and transgressions inside their communities?
Great episode Alex! Will we ever see Louise Perry make a return to the show? She talks more now about demography and collapse Especially in the context of Britain. It’s fascinating but kinda terrifying. I would love to see her back on! x
Freya India would also make for a great guest. Her work is amazing :)
Let’s compare crime rates in the UK with those in Poland. I’m giving the crime index measured as crimes per 1,000 residents (so the higher the number the more crime), and safety index scores from 0-100, where a low figure means people feel very unsafe and a high score means they feel very safe.
UK crime index 48.
Poland crime index 25.
In other words, crime in the UK is running at maybe twice the level of Poland. Figures for individual cities suggest that the disparity is actually far greater.
Polish Safety Perceptions:
People in Poland feel safer walking alone both during the day (83.35) and at night (61.70) compared to the UK, where safety is rated at 67.49 for daytime and 41.93 for nighttime.
Specific Crime Concerns:
The UK has more issues with drug-related crimes, with a score of 63.61 compared to Poland’s 28.29. Property crimes and vandalism are also much higher in the UK.
Violent crime, such as assault and armed robbery, is more prevalent in the UK, with a score of 46.08, compared to a very low 18.18 in Poland.
Individual cities:
Warsaw, the Polish capital, has a crime index of 25.3 and a safety index of 74.7. The city is considered very safe for walking alone during the day (88.8) and fairly safe at night (67.9). Most types of violent crime, such as assault and robbery, are rare. I couldn’t find figures for Poland’s second and third cities Kraków and Łódź, but the impression is, they’re lower than Warsaw.
Here are the crime index figures for some English cities, compared to Warsaw:
Warsaw: 25.3.
Birmingham: 128.9.
Bradford: 132.4
Leeds: 133.3.
Nottingham: 134.1.
Liverpool: 136.7.
Manchester: 172.6.
Original comment by @georgesdelatour on yt